Prebiotics vs Probiotics: What Your Gut Actually Needs

Prebiotics vs Probiotics

Prebiotics vs Probiotics: What’s the Difference and What Does Your Gut Need?

Quick answer: Probiotics are live microorganisms, found in some fermented foods and supplements, that may offer a health benefit. Prebiotics are the fibers and starches that feed the microbes already living in your gut. You get prebiotics from plant foods like onions, garlic, leeks, asparagus, slightly green bananas, tubers such as tiger nuts, and (if you eat them) legumes and whole grains. Most healthy people don’t need supplements of either: a varied, fiber-rich diet with some fermented foods covers both. Supplements are best discussed with your doctor.

What are probiotics?

Probiotics are live microorganisms, usually bacteria or yeasts, intended to have a health benefit when eaten. Common types include *Lactobacillus*, *Bifidobacterium* and the yeast *Saccharomyces boulardii*.

According to the NCCIH:

  • Probiotics may help some people with specific problems, such as preventing antibiotic-associated diarrhea, but results vary by strain
  • Benefits found for one strain can’t be assumed for others
  • Not all fermented foods contain live probiotic microbes, because some are heated or filtered after fermentation
  • Probiotics are generally safe for healthy people, but people with weakened immune systems or serious illnesses should talk to their doctor first

Food sources of live microbes

  • Yogurt and kefir labeled “live and active cultures”
  • Coconut or dairy-free yogurts with added cultures
  • Raw (unpasteurized-after-fermentation) sauerkraut and kimchi from the chilled section
  • Kombucha
  • Miso and tempeh (not paleo or AIP, as they’re made from soy)

What are prebiotics?

Prebiotics are compounds, mostly certain fibers, that the beneficial microbes in your gut can ferment. When they do, they produce short-chain fatty acids that the cells of your colon use for energy.

Common prebiotic fibers include inulin, fructooligosaccharides (FOS), galactooligosaccharides (GOS) and resistant starch.

Food sources of prebiotics

FoodMain typePaleo?AIP elimination?
Onions, garlic, leeksInulin, FOSYesYes
Asparagus, artichokesInulinYesYes
Slightly green bananas, plantainsResistant starchYesYes
Cooked and cooled potatoes or cassavaResistant starchCooled cassava yes; white potatoes varyCassava yes; white potato no
Tiger nutsFiber, some resistant starchYesYes
ApplesPectinYesYes
Beans and lentilsGOS, resistant starchNoNo
Oats, barleyBeta-glucanNoNo

Tiger nuts are a handy option for paleo and AIP diets because they’re tubers, not nuts or grains. A review of tiger nut composition describes them as high in dietary fiber. Human studies on tiger nuts and the microbiome are limited, so we describe them as fiber-rich rather than a proven gut treatment. Read more in are tiger nuts prebiotic.

Whole tiger nuts, a fiber-rich prebiotic food for paleo and AIP diets

Prebiotics vs probiotics side by side

PrebioticsProbiotics
What they areFibers and starchesLive microorganisms
What they doFeed existing gut microbesAdd microbes, usually temporarily
Where you find themPlant foodsFermented foods, supplements
Affected by heat?Mostly heat-stableHeat kills live cultures
Strength of evidenceStrong for dietary fiber overallVaries by strain and condition
Possible side effectsGas, bloating if increased fastUsually mild; caution if immunocompromised

Which one does your gut actually need?

For most people, the honest answer is: more fiber from a range of plant foods. The Dietary Guidelines for Americans list fiber as a nutrient most people under-eat. A large Stanford study found that a diet high in fermented foods increased microbiome diversity over 10 weeks, while a high-fiber diet did not change diversity in that short time, though it changed other markers. Both food patterns were well tolerated. It’s a reminder that fiber and fermented foods do different things, and eating both is a reasonable approach.

Probiotic supplements may help in specific situations, such as some cases of antibiotic-associated diarrhea, but the right strain and dose matter. If you’re considering one, ask your doctor or pharmacist. If you’re recovering after antibiotics, our guide on rebuilding the gut microbiome after antibiotics has food-first ideas.

How to eat both every day

Breakfast

Tiger nut granola over yogurt with live cultures and sliced banana. That’s fiber from tiger nuts and fruit plus live microbes from the yogurt.

Lunch

A salad with roasted asparagus, red onion and a spoon of raw sauerkraut.

Snack

Apple slices with Original Tiger Nut Butter, or a small handful of soaked whole tiger nuts.

Dinner

Cassava or sweet potato that’s been cooked and cooled, then reheated, with garlic-roasted greens. Cooling cooked starches can increase their resistant starch. See resistant starch foods.

Tips for adding prebiotic foods

  • Go slowly. Adding a lot of fiber at once can cause gas and bloating. The NIDDK suggests increasing fiber gradually
  • Drink water as your fiber intake rises
  • Mix sources. Different fibers feed different microbes
  • Be careful with IBS. Many prebiotic foods are high-FODMAP. If you have IBS, work with a dietitian

Tips for choosing fermented foods

  • Look for “live and active cultures” or “contains live cultures”
  • Buy sauerkraut and kimchi from the fridge, not shelf-stable jars
  • Watch the sugar in flavored yogurts and kombucha; check the added sugars line
  • On AIP, choose coconut yogurt with cultures and no added gums you react to

Prebiotics and probiotics on paleo and AIP

Both diets remove some of the most common prebiotic foods, such as beans, lentils, oats and barley, and AIP also removes most fermented dairy during elimination. That makes it worth planning:

  • Prebiotics: lean on onions, garlic, leeks, asparagus, artichokes, plantains, cooled cassava or sweet potato, apples, and tiger nuts or tiger nut flour
  • Probiotics: choose cultured coconut yogurt, coconut kefir, sauerkraut and kimchi without chili (nightshades are excluded on AIP)
  • Variety: rotate vegetables week to week rather than eating the same few

See our AIP granola guide for breakfast ideas that fit.

Who should talk to a doctor first

  • Anyone with a weakened immune system, a central line or a serious illness, before taking probiotic supplements
  • People with IBS, IBD or ongoing digestive symptoms, before making big fiber changes
  • Pregnant people, and parents of premature babies, before using any supplement
  • Anyone with new or worsening symptoms such as blood in the stool, weight loss or persistent pain, which need a medical check rather than a diet change

Common myths

  • “Everyone needs a probiotic supplement.” Not true. Most healthy people can rely on food.
  • “More strains are always better.” There’s no evidence that a higher number of strains means more benefit.
  • “Prebiotics are only in supplements.” Everyday plant foods supply plenty.
  • “Fermented foods fix every gut problem.” Persistent symptoms need a medical check.

For a broader look, see our complete guide to improving gut health and the paleo diet and gut health.

FAQ

What is the difference between prebiotics and probiotics?

Probiotics are live microbes. Prebiotics are the fibers that feed the microbes already in your gut.

Should I take prebiotics and probiotics together?

You can get both from food. Supplements of either should be discussed with your doctor.

What foods are natural prebiotics?

Onions, garlic, leeks, asparagus, slightly green bananas, apples, tiger nuts, and cooked and cooled starchy foods.

Are tiger nuts prebiotic?

They’re rich in fiber and contain some resistant starch, which gut bacteria can ferment. Human research on tiger nuts specifically is limited.

Can probiotics cause side effects?

Usually only mild gas or bloating. People with weakened immune systems should get medical advice first.

Do prebiotics cause gas?

They can, especially if you add a lot quickly. Increase gradually.